Kate Middleton faced criticism from fashion critic Suzy Menkes, who holds an OBE awarded by the late Queen Elizabeth II. Menkes labeled Kate as a “disappointment” due to her perceived lack of enthusiasm towards jewelry compared to Queen Camilla.
To be frank, it’s often so rare to find anyone doubting the Princess of Wales’ prowess in whatever she endeavors. Whether Kate Middleton is showcasing her tennis skills with sporting legends or astonishing millions of fans globally with an unexpected Eurovision appearance, she undeniably excels in various endeavors.
Occasionally, she even sports different personas, as evidenced by this throwback cowboy picture.
However, this week, it’s not her hats that have drawn attention but a different aspect of her style—her affinity for jewelry. Some have labeled her a “disappointment” in this regard.
How it all started
Renowned fashion journalist Suzy Menkes, who served as editor for Vogue International until 2020, made a surprising comment about Kate Middleton’s approach to jewelry.
Speaking on the podcast Creative Conversations with current British Vogue jewelry editor Carol Woolton, Menkes expressed her views on the Princess of Wales’ attitude towards accessories.
According to Menkes, Kate gives off the impression that she only wears jewelry when it’s absolutely necessary. She shared an imaginary scenario of the Princess looking stunning in a gown but seemingly reluctant to wear the accompanying jewelry as if questioning the need for it. Menkes opined that Kate doesn’t convey a sense of adoration for jewelry and enthusiasm to adorn herself with it, unlike Camilla, Duchess of Cornwall.
“The Princess of Wales is a bit of a disappointment about jewellery. She gives the impression that she only puts it on when she absolutely has to,” Suzy stated. “I imagine her looking beautiful in one of those gowns and then her sort of pulling a face as if to say, “Do I have to wear this? I mean, it’s probably ridiculous but she doesn’t give any sense of adoring jewellery and being pleased to put it on.”
Menkes considered the possibility that being a mother might play a role in Kate’s lesser interest in elaborate accessories, as she might prefer to spend less time putting them on. However, the journalist observed that Kate lacks the evident joy that Camilla exudes when wearing jewelry.
The Princess of Wales has had fans rush to her defence
Numerous fans of Kate expressed their disagreement, especially highlighting their admiration for her unique style and skill in combining regal pieces with high-street favorites.
A One X user, (previously Twitter), remarked, “When you have everything, you don’t have to flaunt. The Princess always looks flawless.”
On the other hand, there are compelling counterarguments to Suzy’s opinion. Recently, Kate garnered praise for wearing £45 Wimbledon earrings, showcasing her ability to appreciate more affordable pieces. Moreover, she often chooses jewelry with meaningful and powerful stories behind them, adding a special touch to her ensembles.